Woman Kicked Off Bus for Reading Bible Aloud. Lightbox Effect Makes Things Bigger.

A Seventh-Day Adventist was recently asked to leave a bus in Fort Worth Texas after she refused to stop reading her Bible aloud to her children. It’s probably not possible to get a real sense of who’s right and who’s wrong here: it all depends on whether the bus driver really was enforcing a noise ordinance fairly and equally, or whether there was some discriminatory malice. The details matter. As best as I can read the situation, the woman certainly seems like she had more on her mind than simply reading to her children (she mentions that other passengers encouraged her readings, which certainly sounds more like it was a public show than merely a private reading to kids that got too loud), and may well have been capable of instigating a scene. But who knows?

The included video reveals that the Liberty Legal Institute, a conservative First Amendment organization, is now involved with the case. The bus company’s case is presented by a quick press release citing the noise ordinance. This is balanced against the woman and LLI’s much more detailed side of the story, which is of course tinged with their own rhetorical take on things. Chances of getting the full and unbiased picture here seem low.

Still, I’m on the side of the woman here unless some further evidence comes in. Unless loud reading is really demonstratively dangerous to other passengers or the driver, I’m not sure what justification the (government-run?) bus company has to be so jumpy about even speech that is deliberately annoying and invasive to other passengers. And for all we know, the driver did in fact specifically ask her to stop reading the Bible aloud period, rather than requesting that she do it more quietly.

It’s not an easy issue, because there certainly are safety issues on buses that might require operators to be especially mindful of preventing fights amongst passengers and so forth. Still, the burden is really on the bus company here, and it’s only because they probably cannot give their full account of their side of the story (for legal reasons, since they have less of an ideological axe to grind and so are primarily trying to be careful and avoid costly litigation by saying too much publicly) that I’ll hold off on faulting them for now.

I do have a confession though: one of the main reasons I wanted to blog about this story was just to mention the bizarre stock graphic of a Bible on the cbs webpage. If you click it, you are granted a slightly larger image of the same random Bible picture. You know, just in case you wanted to examine the fine grain of the leather cover more closely!

These sorts of things amuse me mostly because, as a sometime webpage scribe myself, I always empathize the person who was tasked with not only digging around for this pointless, space filling graphic, but also for implementing the “lightbox” technology to make it slightly larger on demand.

5 Responses to Woman Kicked Off Bus for Reading Bible Aloud. Lightbox Effect Makes Things Bigger.

  1. tom rogers says:

    Good morning, Bad.

    In ascending order, from trivial to less:

    I too, have scratched my head at an enlargement of some arbitrary image that only vaguely attaches itself to the subject. Glad I’m not the only one.

    The only real problem I see on the bus sitch, is that what we have is a captive audience, barring “this is where I get off”. If this was a little get-together with like-minded people, listening to one reading bible passages in a normal voice, directed to her group, predominantly, (I realize that evangelizing is an important element of Christianity.) then I’d be suspicious of the Driver’s motives. Were she, instead more loudly broadcasting to the entire bus, that goes, as you say, pretty much over the line.

  2. Bad says:

    Yeah, really just no way for people reading the news story to tell what the truth of the matter is. It would be worthwhile to hear the accounts of people who were actually on the bus, though these probably wouldn’t necessarily be disinterested parties either.

  3. PhillyChief says:

    I’d be just as annoyed if she were reading stereo instructions loudly. Of course maybe she should have been reading into a phone. Sadly it seems people get a pass for being loud and annoying in public if they’re doing so into a phone.

  4. PalMD says:

    I gotta side with the bible thumper. I’d be annoyed as hell, but then, I can just start lecturing on LeVey Satanism on the other side of the bus.

  5. By far the most concise and up to date information I found on this topic. Sure glad that I navigated to your page by accident. I’ll be subscribing to your feed so that I can get the latest updates. Appreciate all the information here

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: